Cambridge University Press
9780521871372 - Egypt in the Byzantine World, 300–700 Edited - by Roger S. Bagnall
Frontmatter/Prelims



EGYPT IN THE BYZANTINE
WORLD, 300–700




Egypt in the period from the reign of the emperor Constantine to the Arab conquest was both a vital part of the late Roman and Byzantine world, participating fully in the culture of its wider Mediterranean society, and a distinctive milieu, launched on a path to developing the Coptic Christian culture that we see fully only after the end of Byzantine rule. This book is the first comprehensive survey of Egypt to treat this entire period including the first half-century of Arab rule. Twenty-one renowned specialists present the history, society, economy, culture, religious institutions, art, and architecture of the period. Topics covered range from elite literature to mummification and from monks to Alexandrian scholars. A full range of Egypt’s uniquely rich source materials – literature, papyrus documents, letters, and archaeological remains – gives exceptional depth and vividness to this portrait of a society, and recent archaeological discoveries are described and illustrated.

ROGER BAGNALL is Professor of Classics and History at Columbia University. He is an internationally acknowledged leader in the field of papyrology and his publications include Egypt in Late Antiquity (1993), The Demography of Roman Egypt (1994, with Bruce Frier), and Reading Papyri, Writing Ancient History (1995).




EGYPT IN THE BYZANTINE
WORLD, 300–700

EDITED BY
Roger S. Bagnall




CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS
Cambridge, New York, Melbourne, Madrid, Cape Town, Singapore, São Paulo

Cambridge University Press
The Edinburgh Building, Cambridge CB2 8RU, UK

Published in the United States of America by Cambridge University Press, New York

www.cambridge.org
Information on this title: www.cambridge.org/9780521871372

© Cambridge University Press 2007

This publication is in copyright. Subject to statutory exception
and to the provisions of relevant collective licensing agreements,
no reproduction of any part may take place without
the written permission of Cambridge University Press.

First published 2007

Printed in the United Kingdom at the University Press, Cambridge

A catalogue record for this publication is available from the British Library

ISBN 978-0-521-87137-2 hardback




Cambridge University Press has no responsibility for the persistence or accuracy of URLs for external
or third-party internet websites referred to in this publication, and does not guarantee that any
content on such websites is, or will remain, accurate or appropriate.




Contents




  List of illustrations page viii
  Preface xiii
  List of abbreviations xiv
1   Introduction 1
  Roger S. Bagnall
Columbia University
 
PART I   THE CULTURE OF BYZANTINE EGYPT
2   Poets and pagans in Byzantine Egypt 21
  Alan Cameron
Columbia University
3   Higher education in early Byzantine Egypt: Rhetoric, Latin, and the law 47
  Raffaella Cribiore
Columbia University
4   Philosophy in its social context 67
  Leslie S. B. MacCoull
Arizona State University
5   Coptic literature in the Byzantine and early Islamic world 83
  Stephen Emmel
University of Münster
6   Early Christian architecture in Egypt and its relationship to the architecture of the Byzantine world 103
  Peter Grossmann
Deutsches Archäologisches Institut-Kairo
7   Coptic and Byzantine textiles found in Egypt: Corpora, collections, and scholarly perspectives 137
  Thelma K. Thomas
University of Michigan
8   Between tradition and innovation: Egyptian funerary practices in late antiquity 163
  Françoise Dunand
Marc Bloch University Strasbourg
 
PART II   GOVERNMENT, ENVIRONMENTS, SOCIETY, AND ECONOMY
9   Alexandria in the fourth to seventh centuries 187
  Zsolt Kiss
Polish Academy of Sciences
10   The other cities in later Roman Egypt 207
  Peter van Minnen
University of Cincinnati
11   Byzantine Egyptian villages 226
  James G. Keenan
Loyola University Chicago
12   The imperial presence: Government and army 244
  Bernhard Palme
University of Vienna
13   Byzantine Egypt and imperial law 271
  Joëlle Beaucamp
CNRS/University of Aix-en-Provence
14   Aristocratic landholding and the economy of Byzantine Egypt 288
  Todd M. Hickey
University of California at Berkeley
15   Gender and society in Byzantine Egypt 309
  T. G. Wilfong
University of Michigan
 
PART III   CHRISTIANITY: THE CHURCH AND MONASTICISM
16   The institutional church 331
  Ewa Wipszycka
University of Warsaw
17   The cult of saints: A haven of continuity in a changing world? 350
  Arietta Papaconstantinou
University of Paris I
18   Divine architects: Designing the monastic dwelling place 368
  Darlene L. Brooks Hedstrom
Wittenberg University
19   Monasticism in Byzantine Egypt: Continuity and memory 390
  James E. Goehring
Mary Washington College
20   Depicting the kingdom of heaven: Paintings and monastic practice in early Byzantine Egypt 408
  Elizabeth S. Bolman
Temple University
 
PART IV   EPILOGUE
21   The Arab conquest of Egypt and the beginning of Muslim rule 437
  Petra M. Sijpesteijn
Christ Church, Oxford
 
  Index 460




Illustrations




6.1   Church of Antinoopolis South (plan: P. Grossmann). page 105
6.2   South-east church of Kellis (Dakhla Oasis) (plan: P. Grossmann). 106
6.3   Sohag, church of Anba Bishuy (plan: P. Grossmann). 108
6.4   Luxor, church in front of the Pylon of the temple of Ammon (plan: P. Grossmann). 109
6.5   Pelusium, church of Tell al-Makhzan south (plan: C. Bonnet). 110
6.6   Abu Mina, North Basilica (plan: P. Grossmann). 111
6.7   Abu Mina, Great Basilica (plan: P. Grossmann). 114
6.8   Abu Mina, Martyr Church (plan: P. Grossmann). 117
6.9   Abu Mina, Eastern Church (plan: P. Grossmann). 118
6.10   Pelusium, circular church (plan: P. Grossmann). 119
6.11   Abu Mina, Baptistery Ⅲ (plan: P. Grossmann). 120
6.12   Sohag, church of the monastery of Anba Shenoute (plan: P. Grossmann). 121
6.13   Quadriburgus from al-Kab (plan: P. Grossmann). 124
6.14   Fortress of Raithou (south Sinai) (plan: P. Grossmann). 125
6.15   Fortress of Tall al-Farama (north-west Pelusium) (plan: P. Grossmann). 126
6.16   Palace on the southern side of the Great Basilica at Abu Mina (plan: P. Grossmann). 129
6.17   Houses of Djeme (ancient Memnonia, after Holscher) (plan: P. Grossmann). 131
7.1   ‘Der Mumientransport’; R. Forrer, Mein Besuch in el-Achmim: Reisebriefe aus Aegypten (Strasbourg 1895). 138
7.2   ‘Les corps après le dépouillement. – Fouilles du cimetière romain’; A. Gayet, Antinoë et les sépultures de Tha\is et Sérapion (Paris 1902). 138
7.3   ‘Leukyoné’; A. Gayet, Fantomes d’Antinoé (Paris 1904). 139
7.4   Plate 442, Dikran G. Kelekian Album of c. 1910. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Gift of Nanette B. Kelekian, in honour of Olga Raggio, 2002 (2002.494.841–7). Image © The Metropolitan Museum of Art. 140
7.5   a, b Matching fragments of a tunic ornament, wool and linen, tapestry weave and weft-wrapping, 1940 purchase, Kelsey Museum of Archaeology 26606 A and B. 143
7.6   ‘Tunika mit Gürtel aus frühbyzantinische Zeit’; R. Forrer, Mein Besuch in el-Achmim. Reisebriefe aus Aegypten (Strasbourg 1895). 144
7.7   Silk, weft-faced compound twill, Panopolis, 1910 purchase, Lyon, Musée des Tissus et des Arts décoratifs, 29.254; photo Pierre Verrier. 145
7.8   ‘Horse and Lion Tapestry’, wool, tapestry weave, Dumbarton Oaks Collection, 39.13; photo Dumbarton Oaks, Byzantine Photographic and Fieldwork Archives, Washington. 148
7.9   Icon of the Virgin, Egypt, Byzantine period, sixth century. Slit and dove-tailed tapestry weave; wool; 178 110 cm. © The Cleveland Museum of Art, Leonard C. Hanna, Jr, Bequest 1967.144. 150
7.10   Diagrams of ornamented tunics; M. Houston, Ancient Greek, Roman and Byzantine Costume and Decoration (London 1931). 151
7.11   Persian coat, wool, tapestry weave, trimmed with silk, from Antinoopolis, fifth–seventh century, Lyon, Musée des Tissus et des Arts décoratifs, Inv. 968, Ⅲ.Ⅰ (34872); photo D. R. 152
7.12   Fragment of a cover, weft-faced compound twill, dyed wools, Karanis 24–5016A, Kelsey Museum of Archaeology, 12798. 154
7.13   Karanis rag amalgam, fabric fragments sewn together in parallel rows of running stitches into a pad of multiple discontinuous layers, Karanis 25–4009A–L, Kelsey Museum of Archaeology, 10375. 155
8.1   Plan of the necropolis of the monks of the Monastery of Epiphanius, Thebes, seventh century AD (after H. Winlock). 165
8.2   Plan of the necropolis of the monks of Abu Fano, fourth century AD (after H. Buschhausen). 166
8.3   Plan of the tomb P1, necropolis of the columbarium, Douch, end of the fourth century AD (after N. Henein). 167
8.4   Mummy P1.2.1.3, necropolis of the columbarium, Douch, end of the fourth century AD; photo R. Lichtenberg. 170
8.5   Mummy P1.2.1.4, necropolis of the columbarium, Douch, end of the fourth century AD; photo R. Lichtenberg. 171
8.6   Mummy ED.W98.1, Christian necropolis of El Deir, fifth century AD; photo F. Dunand. 173
8.7   Mummy ED.W97.1, Christian necropolis of El Deir, fifth century AD; photo F. Dunand. 174
8.8   Mummy called ‘the embroidress’, Antinoopolis, fourth century AD, Brussels, Musées Royaux d’Art et d’Histoire. 175
9.1   Seated porphyry statue, Alexandria, Graeco-Roman Museum inv. no. 5934 (Galerius). 189
9.2   Column from ‘Church of Theonas’ (?) in front of present-day University of Alexandria. 192
9.3   Illustration from the Alexandrian ‘Weltchronik’ in Moscow, Pushkin Museum: Patriarch Theophilus in the destroyed Serapeum. 194
9.4   A sculpture from Sidi Bishr in Alexandria, Graeco-Roman Museum: Aphrodite with Eros. 196
9.5   Marea, Basilica. 197
9.6   The so-called ‘Roman Theatre’ from Kom el-Dikka. 198
9.7   A basket-capital, Alexandria, Graeco-Roman Museum, inv. no. 13475. 199
9.8   One of the auditoria newly discovered at Kom el-Dikka. 199
9.9   Kom el-Dikka, a general view of House D from the quarter east of street R4. 201
9.10   Ivory: medicine box with Isis or Tyche, Dumbarton Oaks. 202
12.1   The provinces of early Byzantine Egypt. 246
14.1   Satellite view of Egypt; photo NASA, 1993. (Freely available for use, see http://visibleearth.nasa. gov/useterms.php). 291
14.2   (a) Pot-garland and (b) saqiya (after M. Venit, The Monumental Tombs of Ancient Alexandria: The Theater of the Dead, Cambridge 2002). 293
14.3   P.Oxy. 2040 (table created by Todd M. Hickey). 297
18.1   Temple of Philae; photo Darlene L. Brooks Hedstrom. 373
18.2   Luxor Temple and remains of two churches; photo Darlene L. Brooks Hedstrom. 374
18.3   Naqlun hills; photo Darlene L. Brooks Hedstrom. 375
18.4   Naqlun hermitage; photo Darlene L. Brooks Hedstrom. 376
18.5   Menshobia at John the Little’s Monastery in Wadi an-Natrun; photo Darlene L. Brooks Hedstrom. 378
18.6   Monastery of Jeremias at Saqqara; photo Darlene L. Brooks Hedstrom. 379
18.7   Kellia; photo Darlene L. Brooks Hedstrom. 380
18.8   Wall painting fragments from John the Little’s Monastery in Wadi an-Natrun; photo Darlene L. Brooks Hedstrom. 386
20.1   Eastern wall including painted cross in a wreath, Kellia (Qusur el-Izeila 19/20, room 15), line drawing; M. Rassart-Debergh, ‘Choix de peintures’, in EK 8184 III (Louvain 1999), chapter 6.3, folding pl. 11, fig. 135. 412
20.2   Western wall, Kellia (Qusur el-Izeila 19/20, room 15), line drawing; Rassart-Debergh, EK 8184 III, folding pl. 11, fig. 137. 413
20.3   Northern wall, Kellia (Qusur el-Izeila 19/20, room 15), line drawing; Rassart-Debergh, EK 8184 III, folding pl. 11, fig. 134. 413
20.4   Southern wall, Kellia (Qusur el-Izeila 19/20, room 15), line drawing; Rassart-Debergh, EK 8184 III, folding pl. 11, fig. 136. 414
20.5   Monastic garb, including analabos, c. fourth–fifth century, Akhmim, now in the Staatliche Museen zu Berlin; P. Philippus Oppenheim, Das Mönchskleid im Christlichen Altertum (Römische Quartalschrift für christliche Altertumskunde und für Kirchengeschichte 28 Supplementheft) (Freiburg 1931): 213, fig. 71. 416
20.6   ‘Cross with bust of Christ’, painting in niche, eastern wall, Kellia (Qusur al-Rubaiyat 219, room 12), drawing. M. Rassart-Debergh, ‘Quelques croix kelliotes’, in Nubia et Oriens Christianus, ed. Piotr O. Scholz and Reinhard Stempel (Cologne 1987) fig. 3; drawing Lenthéric. 417
20.7   ‘Bear’, Monastery of Apa Apollo, Bawit (cell ⅩⅦ); J. Clédat, Le monastère et la nécropole de Baouît (Cairo 1904), pl. ⅩⅬⅨ. 419
20.8   ‘Hart and Snake’, Monastery of Apa Apollo, Bawit (cell ⅩⅦ); Clédat, Le monastère, pl. ⅩⅬⅨ. 420
20.9   ‘Monastic Saints’, Monastery of Apa Jeremias at Saqqara, (cell A, photograph at time of excavation). This painting, somewhat reduced, is now in the Coptic Museum, Cairo. Jean Quibell, Excavations at Saqqara (1906–1907) (Cairo 1908), pl. ⅩⅬⅣ. 421
20.10   ‘St Sisinnius’, Monastery of Apa Apollo at Bawit (cell ⅩⅦ). Clédat, Le monastère, pl. ⅬⅤ. 422
20.11   ‘Christ in Majesty’, detail of the upper zone showing the enthroned Christ and chariot wheels, eastern niche, Monastery of Apa Apollo at Bawit (cell ⅩⅦ); Clédat, Le monastère, pl. ⅩⅬⅡ. 423
20.12   ‘Ama Rachel’, detail, Monastery of Apa Apollo at Bawit (room 40); Ét. Drioton, Fouilles exécutées à Baouît (MIFAO 59, Cairo 1943), pl. ⅩⅬⅨ. 427
20.13   ‘Cross’, wall painting, eastern end, chapel in the wall, Monastery of St Catherine on Mount Sinai; reproduced through the courtesy of the Michigan–Princeton– Alexandria Expeditions to Mount Sinai. 428
20.14   ‘Cross’, eastern wall above niche, Kellia (Qusur el-Izeila 19/20, room 2); Les Kellia, ermitages coptes en Basse-Egypte, ed. Y. Mottier and N. Bosson (Geneva 1989): 76, fig. 15. 429




Preface




This book began life as the papers given at the annual Byzantine Studies Symposium of Dumbarton Oaks in spring 2004. In planning the symposium, which was the first at Dumbarton Oaks devoted specifically to Egypt, I aimed to bring together speakers who could give the audience a survey of current research and views on as wide a variety of topics as possible. Inevitably, considerations of the symposium’s schedule, balance, and budget prevented the inclusion of some topics or speakers. Some – but not all – of the resulting gaps have been remedied in this volume, and I am particularly grateful to those who agreed on relatively short notice to write these chapters. But it was the symposium that furnished the occasion and brought together most of the contents, and I must thank particularly the Director (Edward Keenan) and Senior Fellows of Dumbarton Oaks for entrusting me with the symposiarch’s office for the year and subsequently allowing me free rein in shaping the resulting publication; Alice-Mary Talbot for her unfailing help and guidance in my discharge of that task; and Caitlin McGurk for her efficient and unobtrusive work in making a complicated event a pleasure for the participants. The learned audience asked many incisive questions and pointed us in directions we had not thought of, and they too deserve some of the credit for the result.

Much of the reading and reflection that went into writing the introduction took place during the fall semester 2004, during which I taught a course on Egypt from 300 to 700 while serving as visiting professor of Coptic Studies at the American University in Cairo. I thank my colleagues there, particularly Salima Ikram, for this stimulating opportunity. Most of the editing of the volume and the actual writing of the introduction were done during early 2005, when I was in the Dakhla Oasis directing Columbia University’s fieldwork there as part of the Dakhleh Oasis Project. The suggestions of the Press’s referees have been helpful at many points in shaping the book. The editorial work, then and subsequently, especially on regularizing the bibliographies, owes much to my graduate assistants, Jason Governale and Giovanni Ruffini.




Abbreviations




Papyri and papyrological series and journals are cited according to Checklist of Editions of Greek, Latin, Demotic and Coptic Papyri, Ostraca and Tablets, ed. J. Oates et al., 5th edn. (BASP Supplement 9, 2001) (also available online at: http://scriptorium.lib.duke.edu/papyrus/texts/clist.html); abbreviations for journals otherwise follow the usage of L’Année Philologique.

AE L’Année Épigraphique (Paris 1888–).
CAG Commentaria in Aristotelem Graeca (Berlin 1882–1909).
CAH Cambridge Ancient History. 2nd edn. (Cambridge 1961–).
CGL Corpus glossariorum Latinorum, ed. G. Goetz. 7 vols. (Leipzig 1893–1901).
CIA Matériaux pour un Corpus Inscriptionum Arabicarum. Première partie: Égypte, ed. M. van Berchem (Mémoires publiés par les membres de l’Institut Français d’Archéologie Orientale du Caire 52, 1894–1930).
CIL Corpus inscriptionum Latinarum (Berlin 1862–).
Coptic Encyclopedia Coptic Encyclopedia, ed. A. S. Atiya. 8 vols. (New York 1991).
CSBE Bagnall, R. S. and K. A. Worp, Chronological Systems of Byzantine Egypt. 2nd edn. (Leiden 2004).
CSCO Corpus scriptorum Christianorum Orientalium.
FHN Fontes historiae Nubiorum. 4 vols. (Bergen 1994–2000).
I.Philae Les inscriptions grecques de Philae, ed. A. Bernand and E. Bernand. 2 vols. (Paris 1969).
OCA Orientalia Christiana analecta (Rome 1923–).
P.Berl.Arab. II Arabische Briefe des 7. bis 13. Jahrhunderts aus den Staatlichen Museen Berlin, ed. W. Diem (Documenta Arabica Antiqua 4, Wiesbaden 1997).
P.Cair.Arab. I-VI Arabic Papyri in the Egyptian Library, ed. A. Grohmann (Cairo 1934–62).
PG Patrologiae cursus completus, series Graeca, ed. J. P. Migne (Paris 1844–91).
P.Heid.Arab. I Papyri Schott–Reinhardt I, ed. C. H. Becker (Heidelberg 1906).
P.Khalili I Arabic Papyri: Selected Material from the Khalili Collection, ed. G. Khan (Oxford 1992).
PL Patrologiae cursus completus, series Latina, ed. J. P. Migne (Paris 1844–79).
PLRE Prosopography of the Later Roman Empire, ed. A. H. M. Jones, J. R. Martindale, and J. Morris. 3 vols. in 4 (Cambridge 1971–92).
PO Patrologia Orientalis (Paris 1907–).
P.Prag.Arab. ‘Arabische Papyri aus der Sammlung Carl Wessely im orientalischen Institute (Orientální 'Ustav) zu Prag’, ed. A. Grohmann, Archiv Orientální 10 (1938): 149–62; 11 (1939): 242–89; 12 (1941): 1–112; 14 (1943): 161–260.
RCEA Répertoire chronologique d’épigraphie arabe I, ed. Ét. Combe, J. Sauvaget, and G. Wiet (Cairo 1931).
SEG Supplementum Epigraphicum Graecum (Leiden 1923–).




© Cambridge University Press