Cambridge University Press
978-0-521-83231-1 - The Cambridge History Of The Byzantine Empire c. 500–1492 - by Jonathan Shepard
Frontmatter/Prelims



THE CAMBRIDGE HISTORY OF THE
BYZANTINE EMPIRE c. 500–1492



Byzantium lasted a thousand years, ruled to the end by self-styled ‘emperors of the Romans’. It underwent kaleidoscopic territorial and structural changes, yet recovered repeatedly from disaster: even after the near-impregnable Constantinople fell in 1204, variant forms of the empire reconstituted themselves. The Cambridge History of the Byzantine Empire tells the story, tracing political and military events, religious controversies and economic change. It offers clear, authoritative chapters on the main events and periods, with more detailed chapters on outlying regions and neighbouring societies and powers of Byzantium. With aids such as maps, a glossary, an alternative place-name table and references to English translations of sources, it will be valuable as an introduction. However, it also offers stimulating new approaches and important findings, making it essential reading for postgraduates and for specialists.

JONATHAN SHEPARD was for many years a Lecturer in History at the University of Cambridge, and was a Fellow of Selwyn College and of Peterhouse. He is the co-editor (with Simon Franklin) of Byzantine Diplomacy (1992), co-author (also with Simon Franklin) of The Emergence of Rus, 750–1200 (1996), author of Nespokoini s’sedi: b’lgaro-vizantiiska konfrontatsiia, obmen i s’zhitelstvo prez srednite vekove [Uneasy Neighbours: Bulgaro-Byzantine Confrontation, Exchange and Co-exist- ence in the Middle Ages] (2007) and editor of The Expansion of Orthodox Europe: Byzantium, the Balkans and Russia (2007). Shepard is Doctor Honoris Causa of St Kliment Ohrid University in Sofia.





THE CAMBRIDGE
HISTORY OF THE
BYZANTINE EMPIRE
c. 500–1492

Edited by
JONATHAN SHEPARD





CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS
Cambridge, New York, Melbourne, Madrid, Cape Town, Singapore, São Paulo, Delhi

Cambridge University Press
The Edinburgh Building, Cambridge CB2 8RU, UK

Published in the United States of America by Cambridge University Press, New York

www.cambridge.org
Information on this title: www.cambridge.org/9780521832311

© Cambridge University Press 2008

This publication is in copyright. Subject to statutory exception
and to the provisions of relevant collective licensing agreements,
no reproduction of any part may take place without
the written permission of Cambridge University Press.

First published 2008

Printed in the United Kingdom at the University Press, Cambridge

A catalogue record for this publication is available from the British Library

Library of Congress Cataloguing in Publication data
The Cambridge history of the Byzantine Empire c. 500–1492 / edited by
Jonathan Shepard.
   p.   cm.
Includes bibliographical references and index.
ISBN 978-0-521-83231-1
1. Byzantine Empire – History – 527–1081. 2. Byzantine Empire – History – 1081–1453.
I. Shepard, Jonathan. II. Title.
DF571.C34   2008
949.5ʹ02 – dc22   2008038886

ISBN 978-0-521-83231-1 hardback



Cambridge University Press has no responsibility for the persistence or
accuracy of URLs for external or third-party internet websites referred to
in this publication, and does not guarantee that any content on such
websites is, or will remain, accurate or appropriate.





Contents



  List of maps page xi
  List of illustrations xi
  List of tables xiv
  Preface xvii
  GENERAL INTRODUCTION
  JONATHAN SHEPARD
Formerly Lecturer in History, University of Cambridge
  i   Approaching Byzantium 2
  ii   Periodisation and the contents of this book 21
  iii   Other routes to Byzantium 53
  iv   Smoothing the way and short-cuts to Byzantium: texts in translation 76
PART I:   THE EARLIER EMPIRE c. 500–c. 700
  1   Justinian and his legacy (500–600) 99
       ANDREW LOUTH, Professor of Patristic and Byzantine Studies, University of Durham
  2   Eastern neighbours
  2a   Persia and the Sasanian monarchy (224–651) 130
       ZEEV RUBIN, Professor of Ancient History, Tel-Aviv University
  2b   Armenia (400–600) 156
       R. W. THOMSON, Formerly Calouste Gulbenkian Professor of Armenian Studies, University of Oxford
  2c   The Arabs to the time of the Prophet 173
       LAWRENCE I. CONRAD, Professor of the History and Culture of the Middle East, Asia–Africa Institute, University of Hamburg
  3   Western approaches (500–600) 196
       JOHN MOORHEAD, McCaughey Professor of History, University of Queensland
  4   Byzantium transforming (600–700) 221
       ANDREW LOUTH
PART II:   THE MIDDLE EMPIRE c. 700–1204
  5   State of emergency (700–850) 251
       MARIE-FRANCE AUZéPY, Emeritus Professor of History, University of Paris Ⅷ
  6   After iconoclasm (850–886) 292
       SHAUN TOUGHER, Senior Lecturer in Ancient History, Cardiff School of History and Archaeology, Cardiff University
  7   Religious missions 305
       SERGEY A. IVANOV, Professor of Byzantine Literature, Moscow State University
  8   Armenian neighbours (600–1045) 333
       T. W. GREENWOOD, Lecturer in Mediaeval History, University of St Andrews
  9   Confronting Islam: emperors versus caliphs (641–c. 850) 365
       WALTER E. KAEGI, Professor of History, University of Chicago
  10   Western approaches (700–900) 395
       MICHAEL M c CORMICK, Francis Goelet Professor of Medieval History, Harvard University
  11   Byzantine Italy (680–876) 433
       THOMAS S. BROWN, Reader in History, University of Edinburgh
  12   The middle Byzantine economy (600–1204) 465
       MARK WHITTOW, Lecturer in Modern History, University of Oxford
  13   Equilibrium to expansion (886–1025) 493
       JONATHAN SHEPARD
  14   Western approaches (900–1025) 537
       JONATHAN SHEPARD
  15   Byzantium and southern Italy (876–1000) 560
       G. A. LOUD, Professor of Medieval Italian History, University of Leeds
  16   Belle époque or crisis? (1025–1118) 583
       MICHAEL ANGOLD, Professor Emeritus of Byzantine History, University of Edinburgh
  17   The empire of the Komnenoi (1118–1204) 627
       PAUL MAGDALINO, Bishop Wardlaw Professor of Byzantine History, University of St Andrews
  18   Balkan borderlands (1018–1204) 664
       PAUL STEPHENSON, Reader in Medieval History, University of Durham
  19   Raiders and neighbours: the Turks (1040–1304) 692
       D. A. KOROBEINIKOV, Wolfson College, University of Oxford
PART III:   THE BYZANTINE LANDS IN THE LATER MIDDLE AGES 1204–1492
  20   After the Fourth Crusade
  20a   The Greek rump states and the recovery of Byzantium 731
       MICHAEL ANGOLD
  20b   The Latin empire of Constantinople and the Frankish states 759
       DAVID JACOBY, Emeritus Professor of History, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem
  21   Balkan powers: Albania, Serbia and Bulgaria (1200–1300) 779
       ALAIN DUCELLIER, Emeritus Professor of History, University of Toulouse – Le Mirail
  22   The Palaiologoi and the world around them (1261–1400) 803
       ANGELIKI E. LAIOU, Dumbarton Oaks Professor of Byzantine History, Harvard University
  23   Latins in the Aegean and the Balkans (1300–1400) 834
       MICHEL BALARD, Emeritus Professor of History, University of Paris I – Panthéon-Sorbonne
  24   The Roman orthodox world (1393–1492) 852
       ANTHONY BRYER, Emeritus Professor of History, University of Birmingham
  Glossary (including some proper names) 881
  Genealogical tables and lists of rulers 906
  List of alternative place names 930
  Bibliography 936
        Notes on use 936
        Abbreviations 938
        Primary sources 946
        Manuscripts 983
        Secondary works
           General and frequently cited works 984
           Part Ⅰ (c. 500–c. 700) 990
           Part Ⅱ (c. 700–1204) 1017
           Part Ⅲ (1204–1492) 1084
        Unpublished theses 1117
  Picture acknowledgements 1119
  Index 1124




Maps



1   Physical geography of the Byzantine world 12
2   Middle Byzantine ‘hot-spots’ 35
3a, b   Archaic, and other less familiar, names 91
4   An empire of cities: Byzantium c. 500 100
5   East Rome into west: expansion under Justinian 110
6   Constantinople in the earlier Byzantine period 113
7   Sasanian Persia 131
8   The Armenian lands in the earlier Byzantine period 158
9   Pre-Islamic Arabia and its northern neighbours 181
10   Lands of the empire in the west in the sixth century 197
11   Byzantium transforming: the empire towards the end of the seventh century 222
12   The empire in the eighth and ninth centuries 252
13   The empire under militarised rule: army units and embryonic themes, earlier eighth century 262
14   Administrative organisation: themes in the later ninth century 263
15   Byzantine religious missions 306
16   Armenia 591–850 334
17   Armenia and imperial expansion 850–1045 350
18   The expansion of Islam 632–850 366
19   Byzantium versus Islam: the zone of direct confrontation 371
20   Western neighbours c. 700–c. 1025 396
21   Italy 700–900 434
22   The Byzantine economic world 466
23   The empire in the tenth and eleventh centuries 494
24   Administrative organisation of the empire at the end of Basil Ⅱ’s reign c. 1025 534
25   Southern Italy in the tenth century 561
26   Cross-currents: Byzantine building- and decorative works in the later tenth and eleventh centuries, and the course of the First Crusade 594
27   Constantinople in the middle Byzantine period: new building-work, major repairs and embellishments 596
28   The empire and its neighbours in the twelfth century 635
29   The Balkans: physical geography and regions 666
30   The imperial mesh in the Balkans, eleventh and twelfth centuries 667
31   Central Asia, the Abbasid caliphate and the emergence of the Seljuqs 695
32   The coming of the Turks: Asia Minor c. 1040–c. 1100 700
33   Byzantine Asia Minor, the Seljuqs of Rum and other Turks 712
34   The coming of the Mongols 720
35   Asia Minor c. 1265 725
36   The Greek-speaking rump states 1204–1261 732
37   The Latin empire of Constantinople and the Frankish states 760
38   Albania 780
39   Theodore Angelos’ seizure of Thrace 1225 786
40   Spanning the Egnatian Way 789
41   Klokotnitsa and Ivan Ⅱ Asen’s counter-offensive 1230 790
42   Manfred of Hohenstaufen’s acquisitions c. 1257, and subsequent dowry settlement by Michael Ⅱ Angelos of Epiros 795
43   Serb expansionism in the late thirteenth century 802
44   The empire reconstituted and lost: Byzantium (a) in the late thirteenth century, and (b) in the 1330s 807
45   The fall of western Asia Minor to the Turks in the first half of the fourteenth century 808
46   Towns and trade in the fourteenth century 819
47   Under pressure from the Serbs, then Turks: Byzantium in the mid- to late fourteenth century 828
48   Greeks and Latins in the Aegean and Balkans 836
49   Ties material and spiritual: the Roman orthodox and the Romance-speaking worlds 848
50   Mount Athos and Mara 873
51   The Pontos in the fifteenth century 877
52   Names of peoples, archaic or less familiar 882




Illustrations



1   The Holy Mountain, Athos 46
2   The walls of Constantinople 57
3   The interior of St Sophia, Constantinople 112
4   Pedestal from the Hippodrome of Constantinople 121
5   Shah Peroz being invested with two diadems 138
6   Inscription from the church of St Gregory at Aruch 162
7a   Plan of fort at Timgad (Thamugadi) in North Africa 204
7b   Justinianic fort at Timgad 205
8a   Mosaic of Justinian from San Vitale, Ravenna 210
8b   Mosaic of Theodora from San Vitale, Ravenna 211
9a   The imperial fleet burns the ships of Thomas the Slav 234
9b   Twenty-first-century Greek fire 234
10   Nomisma of Justinian Ⅱ 236
11a, b   Gold coins of Constantine Ⅵ and Irene 275
12   Zodiac from Ptolemy’s ‘Handy Tables’ 280
13   Manuscript of the Uspensky Gospels 281
14   Theodore the Stoudite, Leo Ⅴ, Patriarch Nikephoros and iconoclasts 290
15   Michael Ⅲ racing near the church of St Mamas 295
16   Basil I being crowned by the Angel Gabriel 303
17   Fresco from Tokale Kilise church in Cappadocia 317
18a, b   Reliquary pectoral crosses from Hungary 323
19   Early example of Glagolitic script 330
20   Early example of Cyrillic script 331
21   View from within the walls of Ani 335
22   The palatine church of Aruch 343
23   The palatine church of Aght‘amar 356
24   The cathedral church of Ani 363
25a, b   Dinars of ‘Abd al-Malik 383
26   The Dome of the Rock, Jerusalem 384
27   Mosaic of Theodore the Stoudite from the monastery of Nea Moni, Chios 403
28   Silver coin of Michael I 418
29   Greek translation of Gregory the Great's Dialogues 428
30   Fresco of a Seraph’s head from Santa Maria Antiqua, Rome 439
31a   The Byzantine hilltop fortress of Sardis 471
31b   Marble column drums reused for the walls at Sardis 472
32   Nomismata of Romanos I Lekapenos 507
33   Ivory of Constantine Ⅶ being crowned and blessed by Christ 514
34   King Abgar of Edessa receiving the mandylion from Christ 515
35   Byzantine cavalry pursuing fleeing Muslims 518
36   The head of Nikephoros Ⅱ Phokas being shown outside the palace 521
37   Basil Ⅱ in parade armour 523
38   Negotiations between Bardas Skleros, the caliphate and Basil Ⅱ 524
39   Ivory of Romanos Ⅱ and Bertha-Eudocia being crowned by Christ 543
40   Ivory of Otto Ⅱ of Germany and Theophano being crowned by Christ 551
41   View of Amalfi's hinterland 578
42   Miniature of Asaph teaching from the book of the law 584
43a, b   The monastery of Nea Moni, Chios: general view and mosaic 593
44   Nomisma (histamenon) of Isaac I Komnenos 604
45   A Byzantine view of the world (miniature) 606
46   Alexios I Komnenos receiving the Panoplia dogmatike 614
47a, b   Alexios I Komnenos’ reformed coinage: a nomisma and a low-value tetarteron noummion 620
48   Monastery of Christ Pantokrator, Constantinople 634
49   Manuel I Komnenos and his second wife Maria of Antioch 643
50   Seal of Leo, imperial spatharokandidatos 669
51   Peter Deljan being proclaimed ruler by his fellow Slavs 671
52a, b   The Armenian Gospel Book of 1066, Sebasteia: title page and miniature of St Mark writing his gospel 693
53   Fifteenth-century picture-map of Constantinople and the Bosporus 753
54   Illustration from the Tomič Psalter 797
55   Illustration from the Radomir Psalter 798
56   Thirteenth-century ‘teratological’ letter design 799
57   Wall-painting of Michael Ⅷ and his family, church of Mother of God, Apollonia 800
58   The Deesis mosaic in St Sophia, Constantinople 826
59   Mosaic of the Grand Logothete Theodore Metochites, Chora monastery, Constantinople 826
60   The shape of the future: a square-rigged cog 847
61   The basileus under western eyes: portrait medal of John Ⅷ Palaiologos by Pisanello 854
62   Bull of union, Florence, 1439 855
63   Engraving of Mistra in the seventeenth century 861
64   The fall of Constantinople, 1453, by Panayotis Zographos 866
65   Grant by Mehmed Ⅱ to the Genoese of Galata, 1453 867
66   Portrait of Sultan Mehmed Ⅱ 870
67   Europe under Ottoman eyes: copy of Ptolemy’s map of Europe 876




Tables



GENEALOGICAL TABLES AND LISTS OF RULERS



Many of the dates and some of the names included in these tables are
debatable, and these lists are therefore somewhat provisional.

1    Byzantine emperors in Constantinople (c. 500–1204 and 1261–1453) page 906
2    Rulers of the Greek ‘rump states’ (1204–1461)
   i Nicaea
908
   ii Greek rulers in the western provinces (Epiros and
      Thessaloniki)
908
   iii Emperors of Trebizond and Grand Komnenoi 908
3    Patriarchs of Constantinople (381–1502) 909
4    Popes of Rome (c. 450–c. 1500) 912
5    Eastern rulers
i   Sasanian Persia 916
ii   Umayyad caliphate; Abbasid caliphate 917
iii   Armenian princes: the principal Bagratuni and Artsruni
      lines
918
iv   Turks: the Seljuq dynasty 919
v   Turks: the Seljuq sultanate of Rum 920
vi   Turks: the Ottoman beylik and sultanate (c. 1282-1566) 920
vii   Mongols: Genghis Khan and his descendants 921
6    Western rulers
i   Frankish emperors/senior co-emperors 921
ii   Western emperors of Saxon origin, and their successors 922
iii   Lombard princes of Capua-Benevento and Salerno 923
iv   Norman rulers of southern Italy 925
7    Balkan rulers
i   Bulgarian rulers 927
ii   Serbian rulers (over the core area of Raška) 928
iii   Hungarian rulers 929
LIST OF ALTERNATIVE PLACE NAMES 930




To Nicola





Preface



This is a short preface for quite a lengthy book, but it is a means of paying tribute to those principally involved in the development, shaping and production of The Cambridge history of the Byzantine empire (or CHBE). Like the empire itself, the process of formation has been protracted, without a clear-cut starting-point, and such sense of direction as has been attained owes more to collaborative effort than it does to untrammelled autocracy.

   Given the sizable number of persons contributing in one way or another, the preface’s brevity entails a mere sketch of those without whose help and advice CHBE would have been a far more onerous and lengthy task. It was Bill Davies who originally encouraged me to take on remodelling materials already available, and several anonymous readers helped structure the volume. Michael Sharp took over from Bill at Cambridge University Press and he has been an extremely patient and supportive editor, ably assisted at various times by Liz Davey, Sinead Moloney, Liz Noden and Annette Youngman. Particular thanks should go to the following key players: Bernard Dod, our indefatigable and eagle-eyed copy-editor, whose attention to detail and wise counsel averted many a mishap; to Barbara Hird, our expert indexer, whose care and clarity have created a valuable additional pathway to Byzantium; to Patricia Jeskins, our assiduous proofreader; and to David Cox, our cartographer, whose splendid maps are closely integrated with the text of our chapters.

   For bibliographic help I have to thank the following colleagues, who have supplied references and answered tiresome queries with speed and good grace: Jean-Claude Cheynet, Florin Curta, Peter Frankopan, Judith Gilliland, Michael Grünbart, Paul Herrup, James Howard-Johnston, Elizabeth Jeffreys, Lester Little, Margaret Mullett, Angel Nikolov, Paolo Odorico, Maureen Perrie, Günter Prinzing, Charlotte Roueché, Maciej Salamon, Alexios Savvides, Teresa Shawcross, John Smedley, Tsvetelin Stepanov, Alice-Mary Talbot, George Tcheishvili, Ida Toth, Vladimir Vavřínek and Mark Whittow. I should also like to thank the staff at the Bodleian, Taylorian Slavonic, Sackler, Oriental Institute and the other Oxford libraries, as well as the staff of the University Library in Cambridge.

   Colleagues who clarified various points along the thousand-year trek, or who freely provided access to unpublished materials of value for this work include Jane Baun, Jeffrey Featherstone, Paul Fouracre, John Haldon, Rosemary Morris, Pananos Sophoulis and Monica White. Particular thanks are due to Catherine Holmes, Mike Maas and Andrew Roach, who read the introduction and some of the chapters that follow, and who warned of culs-de-sac and quicksands to be charted or – hopefully – avoided.

   On the technical side, help with translation and transliteration was given by Lawrence Conrad, Jeffrey Featherstone, Tim Greenwood, Mona Hamami and Marina Kujić. Jenny Perry saved me on several occasions when Macs failed to talk to PCs, and vice versa, while Nigel James of the Bodleian initiated me into the mysteries of digital map-making. Locating and sourcing illustrations was made easier through the assistance of Nancy Alderson, Michel Balard, Theodore van Lint, Cyril Mango, Nicholas Mayhew, Dorothy McCarthy, Denys Pringle, Michael Stone and Robert Thomson. Particular thanks go to our neighbours, Vanessa and Peter Winchester, to whom I am indebted for several pictures of Constantinople. These thanks should be accompanied by apologies for a certain lack of sociability in recent years – and extended to all remaining friends.

   It is a commonplace to thank one’s immediate family for their help and endurance in these endeavours. However, I must single out my wife, Nicola, who took on the role of editorial assistant on the project without, I think, appreciating the sheer scale of activity involved. As I have often pointed out to her, this could be seen as due penance for failing to attend my lectures on Byzantium and its neighbours all those years ago in Cambridge! Without Nicola, the volume would probably not have been published this decade, and I am profoundly grateful for her patience, counsel and support.

   However, those most indispensable are the volume’s contributors. The chapters whose first incarnation was in The Cambridge ancient history or The new Cambridge medieval history have been joined by important new contributions expanding and elaborating on relevant themes. But it goes without saying that, notwithstanding all the help and advice received along the way, I take responsibility for such mistakes or errors as may have crept into the finished work.



NOTES ON USING THIS VOLUME

Our approach to transliteration may induce unease among some colleagues – and invite charges of inconsistency – but we have tried to make proper names and technical terms accessible to the English-speaking world wherever possible. Greek has been transliterated and bars have been used to distinguish ēta from epsilon and ōmega from omicron in the case of individual words and technical terms, but abandoned for proper names. Greek forms of proper names have generally been adopted in Parts and – Komnenos instead of the Latinised Comnenus, for example – in contrast to Part I, set in late antiquity, when Latinised names seem appropriate. In general, we have adopted a ‘b’ and not ‘ⅴ’ when transliterating the Greek letter bēta. However, where a name is more or less domiciled in English usage, we have let it be, e.g. Monemvasia and not Monembasia. Where the names of places are probably so familiar to most readers in their Latinised forms that the use of a Greek form might distract, the Latinised form has been retained in Parts and – Nicaea instead of Nikaia, for example. Familiar English forms have been preferred out of the same consideration – Athens not Athenai, for example – and in Part , when the empire’s possessions were being taken over by speakers of other tongues, the place names now prevalent have generally been preferred – Ankara instead of Ankyra, for example.

   Arabic diacritics have been discarded in proper names, with only the ayn (’) and hamza (‘) retained in the form shown, on the assumption that the diacritics will not help non-Arabic readers and may actually distract from name recognition and recall; however, full diacritics have been retained for individual words and technical terms. We have tried to be consistent yet accessible in transliterating other key scripts, such as Armenian and Cyrillic, using for the latter a modified version of the Library of Congress system.

   Detailed notes on how to use the bibliography can be found below at pp. 936–8. Chronological sectioning for the secondary bibliography is – like the periodisation of history itself into mutually exclusive compartments – rather arbitrary. The bibliography of secondary works should therefore be treated as a whole and the reader failing to find a work in one section should try the others.

   The Glossary and Tables are not intended to be comprehensive guides. The Glossary offers a selection of the technical terms, foreign words and names of peoples and institutions appearing in CHBE. But wherever possible, these are explained in the context of a chapter and only the more problematic proper names have a Glossary entry (see also Maps 3 and 52). Likewise, the lists of rulers and genealogies have been kept to a minimum, since they are available in more specialised works. The list of alternative place names is intended to help the reader locate some towns and regions which were known under radically different names by diverse occupants or neighbours, and to offer modern equivalents where known.

   The maps are designed to reconcile accessibility for anglophone readers with a sense of the form prevalent during the chronological section of CHBE in question, not wholly compatible goals. The maps are intended to be viewed as an ensemble, and readers unable to spot a place in a map positioned in one chapter should look to adjoining chapters, or (aided by the list of alternative place names and the index) shop around.





© Cambridge University Press