This is the first systematic exploration of the nature and extent of sympathy for Nazi Germany at American universities during the 1930s. Universities were highly influential in shaping public opinion, and many of the nation's most prominent university administrators refused to take a principled stand against the Hitler regime. Universities welcomed Nazi officials to campus and participated enthusiastically in student exchange programs with Nazified universities in Germany. American educators helped Nazi Germany improve its image in the West as it intensified its persecution of the Jews and strengthened its armed forces. The study contrasts the significant American grassroots protest against Nazism that emerged as soon as Hitler assumed power with campus quiescence, and with administrators’ frequently harsh treatment of those students and professors who challenged their determination to maintain friendly relations with Nazi Germany.
Stephen H. Norwood, who holds a Ph.D. from Columbia University, is Professor of History at the University of Oklahoma. His two-volume Encyclopedia of American Jewish History, co-edited with Eunice G. Pollack (2008), received the Booklist Editor's Choice Award. He is also the author of three other books in American history and the winner of the Herbert G. Gutman Award in American Social History and co-winner of the Macmillan/SABR Award in Baseball History. His articles have appeared in anthologies and numerous journals, including American Jewish History, Modern Judaism, and the Journal of Social History.
To Eunice G. Pollack
CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS
Cambridge, New York, Melbourne, Madrid, Cape Town, Singapore, São Paulo, Delhi
Cambridge University Press
32 Avenue of the Americas, New York, NY 10013-2473, USA
www.cambridge.org
Information on this title: www.cambridge.org/9780521762434
© Stephen H. Norwood 2009
This publication is in copyright. Subject to statutory exception and to the provisions of relevant collective licensing agreements, no reproduction of any part may take place without the written permission of Cambridge University Press.
First published 2009
Printed in the United States of America
A catalog record for this publication is available from the British Library.
Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication dataNorwood, Stephen H. (Stephen Harlan), 1951–The Third Reich in the ivory tower : complicity and conflict on Americancampuses / Stephen H. Norwood.p. cm.Includes bibliographical references and index.ISBN 978-0-521-76243-4 (hardback)1. Education, Higher – United States – History – 20th century. 2. National socialismand education – United States – History. I. Title.LA227.1.N67 2009378.73′09043–dc22 2008046266
ISBN 978-0-521-76243-4 hardback
Cambridge University Press has no responsibility for the persistence or accuracy of URLs for external or third-party Internet Web sites referred to in this publication and does not guarantee that any content on such Web sites is, or will remain, accurate or appropriate. Information regarding prices, travel timetables, and other factual information given in this work are correct at the time of first printing, but Cambridge University Press does not guarantee the accuracy of such information thereafter.
|
Figures
|
vi |
|
Abbreviations
|
ix |
|
1 Germany Reverts to the Dark Ages: Nazi Clarity and Grassroots American Protest, 1933–1934
|
1 |
|
2 Legitimating Nazism: Harvard University and the Hitler Regime, 1933–1937
|
36 |
|
3 Complicity and Conflict: Columbia University's Response to Fascism, 1933–1937
|
75 |
|
4 The Seven Sisters Colleges and the Third Reich: Promoting Fellowship Through Student Exchange
|
103 |
|
5 A Respectful Hearing for Nazi Germany's Apologists: The University of Virginia Institute of Public Affairs Roundtables, 1933–1941
|
133 |
|
6 Nazi Nests: German Departments in American Universities, 1933–1941
|
158 |
|
7 American Catholic Universities’ Flirtation with Fascism
|
196 |
|
8 1938, Year of the Kristallnacht: The Limits of Campus Protest
|
220 |
|
Epilogue
|
243 |
|
Notes
|
257 |
|
Bibliography
|
305 |
|
Index
|
317 |
|
1.1 Every available seat in New York City's Madison Square Garden is filled at a mass rally against antisemitism in Nazi Germany,
March 27, 1933.
|
13 |
|
1.2 Mass demonstration against Nazi antisemitism in the heavily Jewish neighborhood of Brownsville in Brooklyn, New York, Stone
and Pitkin Avenues, March 27, 1933.
|
14 |
|
1.3 Anti-Nazi protesters march through New York City's Washington Square Park on their way to a mass rally in Battery Park against
antisemitism in Germany, May 10, 1933.
|
21 |
|
2.1 Dr. Hans Luther, Nazi Germany's ambassador to the United States, gives the Nazi salute on board the Karlsruhe during its visit to Boston, May 1934.
|
43 |
|
2.2 Officers and diplomats from Nazi Germany at Baron von Tippelskirch's estate in Newton, Massachusetts, May 1934. Left to right:
(front row) Baron Kurt von Tippelskirch, Nazi Germany's consul general in Boston; Captain von Enderndorf of the Karlsruhe; Dr. Hans Luther, Nazi Germany's ambassador to the United States; and Baroness von Tippelskirch and (back row) General Boetticher;
Captain Witthoeft; and Lt. Commanders Gadow and Krabbe.
|
46 |
|
2.3 Diplomats from Nazi Germany at Harvard's Germanic Museum, May 1934. Left to right: Baron Kurt von Tippelskirch, Nazi Germany's
consul general in Boston; Dr. Hans Luther, Nazi Germany's ambassador to the United States; and Gerrit von Haeften, attaché
at the German embassy in Washington.
|
47 |
|
2.4 Ernst Hanfstaengl (right) with Frank J. Reynolds at the Harvard Class of 1909 reunion, June 1934.
|
51 |
|
2.5 Rabbi Joseph Solomon Shubow (center), who confronted Ernst Hanfstaengl in Harvard Yard in June 1934 and demanded to know whether
the Nazi plan for the Jews was extermination.
|
52 |
|
2.6 Ernst Hanfstaengl speaking with newspaper reporters at Harvard, June 1934.
|
53 |
|
2.7 Ernst Hanfstaengl (center, with raised arm) in the Harvard Class of 1909 parade, June 1934.
|
54 |
|
2.8 Dr. Hans Luther (right), Nazi Germany's ambassador to the United States, presents Roscoe Pound, dean of Harvard Law School,
with an honorary degree from the University of Berlin, September 1934.
|
56 |
|
3.1 Nazi Germany's ambassador to the United States, Dr. Hans Luther (front row center), in Washington, D.C., April 21, 1933. With
him in the front row, left to right: Dr. Rudolf Leitner, counselor of the German embassy; Gen. Friedrich von Boetticher, military
attaché; Richard Southgate, U.S. State Department; and Dr. Johann Lohman, secretary of the German embassy.
|
77 |
|
3.2 Columbia University president Nicholas Murray Butler and his daughter, Sarah Butler.
|
80 |
|
3.3 Columbia Spectator managing board, 1934–35.
|
81 |
|
3.4 Columbia fine arts instructor Jerome Klein, whose appointment was terminated by President Nicholas Murray Butler because he
protested the administration's welcome to Nazi Germany's ambassador, Hans Luther.
|
86 |
|
3.5 Columbia students carry out mock book burning to protest President Butler's sending a delegate to Nazi Germany to participate
in the University of Heidelberg's 550th anniversary celebration, May 1936.
|
96 |
|
4.1 Toni Sender, Jewish Social Democratic Reichstag deputy (1920–33), who narrowly escaped being murdered by the Nazis, forcefully
denounced Nazi policies toward women while lecturing in the United States.
|
104 |
|
4.2 President Marion Edwards Park of Bryn Mawr College.
|
110 |
|
6.1 “Axis Sally” (Mildred E. Gillars) leaving U.S. District Court in Washington, D.C., during her trial for treason, February
17, 1949.
|
167 |
|
E.1 Retiring U.S. ambassador to West Germany James B. Conant (left) shakes hands with Dr. Hans Globke in Bonn, February 19, 1957.
|
249 |
| AAUP |
American Association of University Professors |
|
| ACLU |
American Civil Liberties Union |
|
| ACUA |
American Catholic History Research Center and University Archives |
|
| ADL |
Anti-Defamation League |
|
| AFL |
American Federation of Labor |
|
| AJC |
American Jewish Committee |
|
| AJCongress |
American Jewish Congress |
|
| AL |
Alexander Library |
|
| ALDJR |
American League for the Defense of Jewish Rights |
|
| ASU |
American Student Union |
|
| AUA |
American University Archives |
|
| BL |
Butler Library |
|
| BMCA |
Bryn Mawr College Archives |
|
| BTCI |
Board of Trustees Committee, Investigation of the Charges of Lienhard Bergel |
|
| CCNY |
City College of New York |
|
| CF |
Central Files |
|
| CU |
Columbia University |
|
| CUACL |
Columbia University Archives – Columbiana Library, Low Library |
|
| CURBML |
Columbia University Rare Book and Manuscript Library |
|
| EC |
Emergency Committee in Aid of Displaced German Scholars |
|
| ECADFS Papers |
Emergency Committee in Aid of Displaced Foreign Scholars Papers |
|
| FBI |
Federal Bureau of Investigation |
|
| FC |
Foreign Counterintelligence |
|
| FS |
Foreign Study |
|
| FSPDS |
Records of Foreign Service Posts of the Department of State |
|
| FSR |
Foreign Study Records |
|
| FUA |
Fordham University Archives |
|
| GLLD |
German Language and Literature Department |
|
| HAA |
Harvard Athletic Association |
|
| HLSP |
Herbert Lehman Suite and Papers |
|
| HUA |
Harvard University Archives |
|
| ICASR |
Intercollegiate Committee to Aid Student Refugees |
|
| IPA |
Institute of Public Affairs |
|
| JBCPP |
James B. Conant Presidential Papers |
|
| JGMP |
James G. McDonald Papers |
|
| JHU |
Johns Hopkins University |
|
| JRAPP |
James R. Angell Presidential Papers |
|
| JSS |
Jewish Students Society |
|
| JTA |
Jewish Telegraphic Agency |
|
| JWV |
Jewish War Veterans of the United States of America |
|
| LC |
Library of Congress |
|
| MAD |
Manuscripts and Archives Division |
|
| MHCA |
Mount Holyoke College Archives |
|
| MIT |
Massachusetts Institute of Technology |
|
| MSEL |
Milton S. Eisenhower Library |
|
| NA |
National Archives |
|
| NCCJ |
National Conference of Christians and Jews |
|
| NCWC |
National Catholic Welfare Conference |
|
| NJC |
New Jersey College for Women |
|
| NSANL |
Non-Sectarian Anti-Nazi League to Champion Human Rights |
|
| NSL |
National Student League |
|
| NYPL |
New York Public Library |
|
| NYU |
New York University |
|
| OAF |
Office Administrative Files |
|
| QCA |
Queens College Archives |
|
| RBML |
Rare Book and Manuscript Library |
|
| RG |
Record Group |
|