This book is a comprehensive study of visual humour in ancient Greece, with special emphasis on works created in Athens and Boeotia. Alexandre G. Mitchell brings an interdisciplinary approach to this topic, combining theories and methods of art history, archaeology, and classics with the anthropology of humour, and thereby establishing new ways of looking at art and visual humour in particular. Understanding what visual humour was to the ancients and how it functioned as a tool of social cohesion is only one facet of this study. Mitchell also focuses on the social truths that his study of humour unveils: democracy and freedom of expression; politics and religion; Greek vases and trends in fashion; market-driven production; proper and improper behaviour; popular versus elite culture; carnival in situ; and the place of women, foreigners, workers, and labourers within the Greek city. Richly illustrated with more than 140 drawings and photographs, as well as with analytical tables of comic representations according to different themes, painters, and techniques, this study amply documents the comic representations that formed an important part of ancient Greek visual language from the sixth through the fourth centuries BC.
A scholar of Greek art and archaeology, Dr. Alexandre G. Mitchell is an Honorary Research Associate at the Institute of Archaeology, University of Oxford.
CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS
Cambridge, New York, Melbourne, Madrid, Cape Town, Singapore, São Paulo, Delhi, Dubai, Tokyo
Cambridge University Press
32 Avenue of the Americas, New York, ny 10013-2473, usa
httt://www.cambridge.org
Information on this title: http://www.cambridge.org/9780521513708
© Alexandre G. Mitchell 2009
This publication is in copyright. Subject to statutory exception and to the provisions of relevant collective licensing agreements, no reproduction of any part may take place without the written permission of Cambridge University Press.
First published 2009
Printed in the United States of America
A catalog record for this publication is available from the British Library.
Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication data
Mitchell, Alexandre G. (Alexandre Guillaume), 1974– Greek vase-painting and the origins of visual humour / Alexandre G. Mitchell. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978–0-521–51370-8 (Hardback) 1. Vase-painting, Greek. 2. Wit and humour, Pictorial. 3. Art and society – Greece.I.Title. NK4645.M62 2009 741.5′938–dc22 2008050635
ISBN 978-0-521-51370-8 Hardback
Cambridge University Press has no responsibility for the persistence or accuracy of urls for external or third-party Internet Web sites referred to in this publication and does not guarantee that any content on such Web sites is, or will remain, accurate or appropriate.
À Lila, ma fille au doux sourire
Amis lecteurs, qui ce livre lisez,Despouillez-vous de toute affection,Et, le lisant, ne vous scandalisez:Il ne contient mal ne infection.Vray est qu’icy peu de perfectionVous apprendrez, sinon en cas de rire,Aultre argument ne peut mon cueur élire,Voyant le dueil qui vous mine et consomme,Mieux est de ris que de larmes escripre,Pour ce que rire est le propre de l’homme.(Rabelais, frontispice to Gargantua 1534)
|
List of Illustrations
|
ix |
|
List of Tables
|
xv |
|
Preface
|
xvii |
|
Acknowledgements
|
xxi |
|
Abbreviations
|
xxiii |
|
One Introduction
|
1 |
|
Two Humour in the City: The World of Men, Women, and Animals
|
36 |
|
Three Humour in the City: Gods, Heroes, and Myth
|
95 |
|
Four Satyrs and Comic Parody
|
150 |
|
Five Caricatures in Athens and at the Kabirion Sanctuary in Boeotia
|
235 |
|
Six Conclusion: Vases, Humour, and Society
|
280 |
|
Glossary
|
317 |
|
Bibliography
|
321 |
|
Index of Vases Cited in the Text
|
345 |
|
General Index
|
357 |
|
1. Olpe, Attic BF, Berkeley, Phoebe Apperson Hearst Museum of Anthropology, 8.3379; Painter of the Jena Kaineus.
|
31 |
|
2. Chous, Attic RF, London, British Museum, E539; Deepdene Painter.
|
32 |
|
3. Cup fr., Attic RF, Athens, National Archaeological Museum, Acropolis Coll., 2. 1073.
|
33 |
|
4. Cup, Attic RF, London, British Museum, E44; Signed Euphronios Epoiesen; Onesimos.
|
34 |
|
5. Attic BF, Hamburg, Museum für Kunst und Gewerbe, 1970.99; Nikosthenes Potter.
|
38 |
|
6. .Cup, Chalcidian BF, Copenhagen, National Museum.
|
42 |
|
7. Cup, Attic RF, Boston, Museum of Fine Arts, 08.31d; Oltos.
|
42 |
|
8a–8b.Cup, Attic BF, Boston, Museum of Fine Arts, 10.651; Amasis Painter.
|
44 |
|
9. Cup, Attic RF, Boston, Museum of Fine Arts, 13.83; Oltos.
|
46 |
|
10. Chous, Attic, Malibu, The J.-Paul Getty Museum, 86.AE.237.
|
49 |
|
11. Pyxis, Attic RF, Berlin, Antikensammlung, F2517; Painter of Bologna 417.
|
50 |
|
12. Chous, Attic, Paris, Musée du Louvre, CA2505.
|
51 |
|
13–14.Pelike, Boeotian RF, Munich, Antikensammlungen, 2347.
|
52 |
|
15. Askos, Attic RF, Oxford, Ashmolean Museum, 539.
|
54 |
|
16. Attic RF, Vatican City, Museo Gregoriano Etrusco Vaticano, 16552; Painter of Bologna 417.
|
55 |
|
17. Pelike, Attic RF, Florence, Museo Archeologico, 72732.
|
56 |
|
18. Hydria, Attic RF, London, British Museum, E202; Washing Painter.
|
59 |
|
19. Northampton Amphora, Ionian BF, Munich, Antikensammlungen, 586.
|
61 |
|
20. Chous, Attic RF, New York, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 37.11.19.
|
65 |
|
21. Hydria, Attic RF, Munich, Antikensammlungen 2421; Phintias.
|
67 |
|
22. Cup, Attic BF, Brussels, Musées Royaux d’Art et d’Histoire, R279; Princeton Painter.
|
69 |
|
23. Stamnos, Attic RF, New York, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 17.230.37; Deepdene Painter.
|
70 |
|
24. Hydria, Attic RF, Madrid, Museo Arqueologico Nacional, 11117; Berlin Painter.
|
73 |
|
25. Hydria, Attic BF, Brussels, Musées Royaux d’Art et d’Histoire, R346.
|
75 |
|
26a–26b.Skyphos, Attic RF, Malibu, The J.-Paul Getty Museum, S80.AE.304.
|
76 |
|
27. Lekythos, Attic RF, London, British Museum, 1922.10–18.1; Oinophile Painter.
|
77 |
|
28. Skyphos, Attic RF, Boston, Museum of Fine Arts, 08.31c.
|
80 |
|
29. Pelike, Attic RF, Syracuse, Museo Archeologico Regionale Paolo Orsi, 20065; Myson.
|
81 |
|
30. Pelike, Attic RF, London, British Museum, E819; Hasselmann Painter.
|
82 |
|
31. Cup, Attic RF, Basel, Antikenmuseum und Sammlung Ludwig, BS1423; Chaire Painter.
|
83 |
|
32. Oinochoe, Attic RF, Hamburg, Museum für Kunst und Gewerbe, 1981.173; Manner of the Triptolemos Painter.
|
84 |
|
33. Skyphos, Attic RF, Oxford, Ashmolean Museum, 520; Epiktetos.
|
88 |
|
34. Cup, Attic RF, Geneva, Musée d’Art et d’Histoire, 16908.
|
88 |
|
35. Chous, Attic RF, Athens, National Archaeological Museum, 17286.
|
89 |
|
36. Cup, Attic RF, Brussels, Musées Royaux d’Art et d’Histoire, R259; Scheurleer Painter.
|
91 |
|
37. Pelike, Attic RF, Laon, Musée Archéologique Municipal, 37.1031; Painter of Munich 2358.
|
92 |
|
38. Pelike, Attic RF, London, British Museum, E387; manner of Washing Painter.
|
93 |
|
39. Neck-amphora fr., Attic BF, Copenhagen, National Museum, 13440; Painter of London B76.
|
97 |
|
40. Chalcidian amphora, Pembroke and Hope (Once); 550–540 BC.
|
98 |
|
41. Hydria, Attic RF, Naples, Museo Archeologico Nazionale, H2422; Kleophrades Painter.
|
100 |
|
42. Cup, Attic RF, Boston, Museum of Fine Arts, Res.08.30.a; Wider Circle of the Nikosthenes Painter.
|
100 |
|
43. Oinochoe, Attic RF, Vatican City, Museo Gregoriano Etrusco Vaticano, 16535; Heimarmene Painter.
|
101 |
|
44. Pelike, Attic RF, Paris, Musée du Louvre, G535; Barclay Painter.
|
104 |
|
45. Askos, Attic RF, Hamburg, Museum fur Kunst und Gewerbe, 1984.457.
|
105 |
|
46. Volute-krater, Attic BF, Florence, Museo Archeologico Nazionale, 4209; Kleitias and Ergotimos.
|
107 |
|
47. Rhyton, Attic RF, St. Petersburg, State Hermitage Museum, 679; Brygos Painter.
|
108 |
|
48. Chous, Attic RF, Paris, Musée du Louvre, N3408; Nikias Painter.
|
110 |
|
49. Amphora, Attic BF, Rome, Museo Nazionale Etrusco di Villa Giulia, 50406; Near Painter of Boulogne 441.
|
112 |
|
50. Pelike, Attic RF, London, British Museum, E370; Washing Painter.
|
113 |
|
51. Pelike, Attic RF, Paris, Bibliothèque Nationale, Cabinet des Médailles, 397; Geras Painter.
|
114 |
|
52. Calyx-krater, Attic RF, Paris, Musée du Louvre, G103; Euphronios.
|
115 |
|
53. Cup, Attic RF, London, British Museum, E83; Codrus Painter.
|
116 |
|
54. Pelike, Attic RF, Rome, Museo Nazionale Etrusco di Villa Giulia, 48238; Matsch Painter.
|
118 |
|
55. Amphora, Attic BF, Syracuse, Museo Archeologico Regionale Paolo Orsi, 21965; Leagros Group.
|
123 |
|
56. Lekythos, Attic BF, New York, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 41.162.29; Sappho Painter.
|
126 |
|
57. Cup, Attic BF, Paris, Musée du Louvre, F121; Nikosthenes Potter.
|
127 |
|
58. Cup, Attic RF, London, British Museum, E66; Clinic Painter.
|
129 |
|
59. Pelike, Attic RF, Tarquinia, Museo Nazionale Tarquiniese, 2989; Nikoxenos Painter.
|
132 |
|
60. Mug, Attic RF, Paris, Musée du Louvre, CA2192.
|
135 |
|
61. Hydria, Caeretan BF, Paris, Musée du Louvre, E702.
|
136 |
|
62. Cup, Attic RF, Vienna, Kunsthistorisches Museum, 3691; Epidromos Painter.
|
138 |
|
63. Cup, Attic RF, Paris, Musée du Louvre, G112; Epidromos Painter.
|
139 |
|
64. Neck-amphora, Attic RF, Naples, Museo di Capodimonte; Group of Polygnotos.
|
140 |
|
65. Cup, Attic RF, Boston, Museum of Fine Arts, 95.28; Painter of Acropolis 356.
|
141 |
|
66. Cup, Attic RF, London, British Museum, E65; Brygos Painter.
|
143 |
|
67. Cup, Attic RF, Rome, Museo Nazionale Etrusco di Villa Giulia, 57912; Epiktetos (by signature).
|
145 |
|
68. Cup, Attic RF, London, British Museum, D2; Pistoxenos Painter.
|
146 |
|
69. Cup, Attic RF, Basel market; (BA 275888); Akestorides Painter.
|
147 |
|
70. Amphora, Attic BF, London, British Museum, B177; Manner of Princeton Painter.
|
148 |
|
71. Bell-krater, Apulian RF, Milan, Moretti collection.
|
152 |
|
72. Chous, Apulian RF, London, British Museum, F366.
|
154 |
|
73. Bell-krater fr., Apulian RF, Malibu, J.-Paul Getty Museum.
|
155 |
|
74. Skyphos, Attic RF, Copenhagen, National Museum, 1943; Zephyros Painter.
|
157 |
|
75. Askos, Attic RF, Warsaw, National Museum, 198897.
|
160 |
|
76. Hydria, Attic RF, Munich. Antikensammlungen, 2422; Phintias.
|
161 |
|
77. Skyphos, Attic RF, St. Petersburg, State Hermitage Museum, 834; Penelope Painter.
|
161 |
|
78. Kyathos, Attic BF, Munich, Antikensammlungen, 1952.
|
163 |
|
79. Cup, Attic RF, Berlin, Antikensammlung, 1964.4; Nikosthenes Painter.
|
164 |
|
80. Nikosthenic Neck-Amphora, Attic BF, Brussels, Musées Royaux d’Art et d’Histoire, R388; Nikosthenes Painter.
|
165 |
|
81. Neck-Amphora, Attic BF, Karlsruhe, Badisches Landesmuseum, 64.52; Nikosthenes Potter.
|
167 |
|
82. Plate, Attic RF, Paris, Bibliothèque Nationale, Cabinet des Médailles, 509; Epiktetos.
|
168 |
|
83. Cup, Attic RF, Palermo, Museo Archeologico Regionale, V651; Skythes.
|
170 |
|
84. Pelike, Attic RF, Genoa, Museo Civico di Archeologia Ligure, 1150.
|
171 |
|
85. Neck-amphora, Attic RF, Paris, Musée du Louvre, G222; Harrow Painter.
|
172 |
|
86. Pelike, Attic RF, London, British Museum, E377; Deepdene Painter.
|
175 |
|
87. Lekythos, Attic RF, Palermo, Museo Archeologico Regionale, 2564; Phiale Painter.
|
176 |
|
88. Mug, Attic RF, Paris, Musée du Louvre, CA3456; Epiktetos.
|
177 |
|
89. Cup, Attic RF, London, British Museum, E3; Epiktetos.
|
178 |
|
90. Kyathos, Attic RF, Paris, Bibliothèque Nationale, Cabinet des Médailles, 848; Onesimos.
|
179 |
|
91. Skyphos, Attic RF, Berlin, Antikensammlung, F2588; Penelope Painter.
|
179 |
|
92. Cup, Attic RF, Paris, Musée du Louvre, G70; Scheurleer Painter.
|
180 |
|
93. Pelike, Attic RF, Dresden, Staatliche Kunstsammlungen Albertinum, ZV2535; Alkimachos Painter.
|
183 |
|
94. Chous, Attic RF, Berlin, Antikensammlung, 1962.33; Altamura Painter.
|
185 |
|
95. Amphora, Attic BF, Leiden, Rijksmuseum van Oudheden, PC9; Dot-Ivy Group.
|
185 |
|
96. Oinochoe fr., Attic RF, New York, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 12.229.13; Harrow Painter.
|
187 |
|
97. Column-Krater, Attic RF, Munich, Antikensammlungen, 2381; Nikoxenos Painter.
|
187 |
|
98. Cup, Attic RF, Boston, Museum of Fine Arts, 01.8024; Makron.
|
189 |
|
99. Cup, Attic RF, Paris, Musée du Louvre, G73; Manner of Scheurleer Painter.
|
190 |
|
100. Skyphos, Attic RF, Habana, Museo Nacional de Bellas Artes, R79–1011; Lewis Painter.
|
192 |
|
101. Pelike, Attic BF, Berlin, Antikensammlung, 3228.
|
194 |
|
102. Cup, Attic RF, Boston, Museum of Fine Arts, 62.613; Manner of the Antiphon Painter.
|
196 |
|
103. Column-krater, Attic RF, London, British Museum, E487; Flying-Angel Painter.
|
198 |
|
104. Cup, Attic RF, Munich, Antikensammlungen, 2592.
|
199 |
|
105. Lekythos, Attic RF, New York market (Once), Royal Athena; Manner of Bowdoin Painter.
|
201 |
|
106. Fr., Attic RF, Tübingen, Eberhard-Karls-Universität, Archäologische Institut, E114; Meidias Painter.
|
203 |
|
107. Chous, Attic RF, Paris, Musée du Louvre, CA493.
|
204 |
|
108. Chous, Attic RF, Berlin, Private collection (BA 2725).
|
205 |
|
109. Cup, Attic BF, Würzburg, Martin von Wagner Museum.
|
206 |
|
110. Volute-krater, Attic RF, Naples, Museo Archeologico Nazionale, 81673; Pronomos Painter.
|
210 |
|
111. Psykter, Attic BF, Brussels, Musées Royaux d’Art et d’Histoire, A1312.
|
213 |
|
112. Volute-krater, Attic BF, Florence, Museo Archeologico Nazionale, 4209; Klitias and Ergotimos.
|
215 |
|
113. Lekythos, Attic RF, Paris, Musée du Louvre, CA1728; CL Class.
|
221 |
|
114. Hydria, Attic RF, London, British Museum, E181; Pan Painter.
|
222 |
|
115. Neck-amphora, Attic RF, Boston, Museum of Fine Arts, 76.46; Charmides Painter.
|
226 |
|
116. Calyx-krater, Attic RF, Lisbon, Foundation Gulbenkian, 682; Group of Polygnotos.
|
227 |
|
117. Calyx-krater, Lucanian RF, London, British Museum, 1947.7–14.8.
|
228 |
|
118. Skyphos, Attic BF, Paris, Bibliothèque Nationale, Cabinet des Médailles, 343; Group of Walter 48.42.
|
229 |
|
119. Oinochoe, Attic BF, London, British Museum, B502; Athena Painter.
|
230 |
|
120. Lekythos, Attic BF, Tübingen, Eberhard-Karls-Universität, Archäologische Institut, S101294; Manner of Sappho Painter.
|
233 |
|
121. Aryballos, Attic RF, Paris, Musée du Louvre, CA2183; Clinic Painter.
|
237 |
|
122. Pelike, Attic RF, St. Petersburg, State Hermitage Museum, B1621; Washing Painter.
|
240 |
|
123. Cup, Attic RF, London, British Museum, E6; Pheidippos.
|
242 |
|
124. Papyrus, London, British Museum, 10016.
|
245 |
|
125. Askos, Attic RF, Paris, Musée du Louvre, G610.
|
246 |
|
126. Skyphos, Attic RF, Laon, Musée Municipal, 37.1034; Amphitrite Painter.
|
247 |
|
127. Kabirion kantharos, Boeotian BF, Berlin, Staatliche Museen, 3286.
|
255 |
|
128. Bell-krater, Attic RF, Reading, Reading Museum and Art Gallery, 45.VIII.1; Meleager Painter.
|
256 |
|
129. Kabirion kantharos, Boeotian BF, Heidelberg, Ruprecht-Karls-Universität, 190.
|
257 |
|
130. Kabirion kantharos fr., Boeotian BF, Athens, National Archaeological Museum, 10426.
|
259 |
|
131. Kabirion kantharos, Boeotian BF, Berlin, Staatliche Museen, 3179.
|
262 |
|
132. Kabirion kantharos, Boeotian BF, Bonn, Akademisches Kunstmuseum, 301.
|
262 |
|
133. Cup, Boeotian BF, Leiden, k94/9,15.
|
264 |
|
134. Kabirion kantharos fr., Boeotian BF, Athens, National Archaeological Museum 10530.
|
265 |
|
135. Kabirion kantharos, Boeotian BF, Athens, National Archaeological Museum, 426.
|
266 |
|
136. Kabirion kantharos fr., Boeotian BF, Bryn Mawr, Ella Riegel Memorial Museum, P217.
|
267 |
|
137. Pyxis, Attic RF, London, British Museum, 1920.12–21.1; Marlay Painter.
|
268 |
|
138. Kabirion kantharos, Boeotian BF, Athens, National Archaeological Museum, 424.
|
269 |
|
139. Kabirion kantharos fr., Boeotian BF, Berlin, Staatliche Museen, 3159.
|
270 |
|
140. Kabirion kantharos, Boeotian BF, Boston, Museum of Fine Arts, 99.533.
|
271 |
|
141. Kabirion skyphos, Boeotian BF, Oxford, Ashmolean Museum, G249 (V262).
|
272 |
|
142. Kabirion kantharos, Boeotian BF, London, British Museum, 1893.3–3.1.
|
273 |
|
143. Kabirion kantharos, Boeotian BF, Athens, National Archaeological Museum, 10429.
|
275 |