OTHELLO
This second edition of Othello updates the first (Bristol Classical Press, 1987), both chronologically and conceptually. It includes consideration of productions from the last seventeen years, and reconsiders earlier material in the light of more recent critical attitudes. Post-colonial and feminist studies have had an impact on the way Othello is perceived and interpreted. The question of blacked-up/black/colour-blind casting and the significance of white and/or black audiences in different political and racial contexts have recently become much more clearly articulated. In the process, Shakespeare himself has not escaped the charge of racism. Equally, the position of Desdemona has received more focused attention, both as the forbidden object of desire within a racial framework and as a woman in her own right. This edition takes account of these developments in criticism, in the theatre, on film and in the adaptations which set out to interrogate Shakespeare’s text.
JULIE HANKEY is a freelance writer and one of the General Editors of the ‘Shakespeare in Production’ series. She contributed the theatre-historical editions of Richard Ⅲ and Othello, before the series was adopted by Cambridge University Press, and has also contributed articles to Shakespeare Quarterly and New Theatre Quarterly.
SERIES EDITORS: J. S. BRATTON AND JULIE HANKEY
This series offers students and researchers the fullest possible stage histories of individual Shakespearean texts. In each volume a substantial introduction presents a conceptual overview of the play, marking out the major stages of its representation and reception. The commentary, presented alongside the New Cambridge Shakespeare edition of the text itself, offers detailed, line-by-line evidence for the overview presented in the introduction, making the volume a flexible tool for further research. The editors have selected interesting and vivid evocations of settings, acting and stage presentation, and range widely in time and space.
ALREADY PUBLISHED
A Midsummer Night’s Dream, edited by Trevor R. Griffiths
Much Ado About Nothing, edited by John F. Cox
Antony and Cleopatra, edited by Richard Madelaine
Hamlet, edited by Robert Hapgood
The Tempest, edited by Christine Dymkowski
King Henry V, edited by Emma Smith
The Merchant of Venice, edited by Charles Edelman
Romeo and Juliet, edited by James N. Loehlin
Macbeth, edited by John Wilders
The Taming of the Shrew, edited by Elizabeth Schafer
As You Like It, edited by Cynthia Marshall
FORTHCOMING VOLUMES
Troilus and Cressida, edited by Frances Shirley
Twelfth Night, edited by Elizabeth Schafer
EDITED BY
JULIE HANKEY
PUBLISHED BY THE PRESS SYNDICATE OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE
The Pitt Building, Trumpington Street, Cambridge, United Kingdom
CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS
The Edinburgh Building, Cambridge, CB2 2RU, UK
40 West 20th Street, New York, NY 10011–4211, USA
477 Williamstown Road, Port Melbourne, VIC 3207, Australia
Ruiz de Alarcón 13, 28014 Madrid, Spain
Dock House, The Waterfront, Cape Town 8001, South Africa
http://www.cambridge.org
© First edition Julie Hankey 1987
© Second edition Cambridge University Press 2005
This book is in copyright. Subject to statutory exception
and to the provisions of relevant collective licensing agreements,
no reproduction of any part may take place without
the written permission of Cambridge University Press.
First published 2005
Printed in the United Kingdom at the University Press, Cambridge
Typefaces EhrhardtMT 10/12.5 pt. and FormataCond System LATEX 2e [TB]
A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library
Library of Congress Cataloguing in Publication data
Shakespeare, William, 1564–1616.
Othello / edited by Julie Hankey – 2nd edn.
p. cm. – (Shakespeare in production)
Includes bibliographical references and index.
ISBN 0 521 83458 9 – ISBN 0 521 54236 7 (pbk)
1. Othello (Fictitious character) – Drama. 2. Shakespeare, William, 1564–1616. Othello – Criticism, Textual. 3. Shakespeare, William, 1564–1616 – Stage history. I. Hankey, Julie. II. Title.
PR2829.A2H36 2005
822.3′3 – dc22 2004054031
ISBN 0 521 83458 9 (hardback)
ISBN 0 521 54236 7 (paperback)
The publisher has used its best endeavours to ensure that the URLs for external websites referred to in this book are correct and active at the time of going to press. However, the publisher has no responsibility for the websites and can make no guarantee that a site will remain live or that the content is or will remain appropriate.
List of illustrations | page vi |
Series editors' preface | vii |
List of abbreviations | ix |
List of productions | xi |
Introduction | 1 |
Othello and commentary | 113 |
Bibliography | 295 |
Index | 307 |
1 | The frontispiece to Rowe’s edition of Othello (1709). By permission of the Shakespeare Centre Library, Stratford-upon-Avon. page 16 |
2 | Edmund Kean as Othello in 3.3. By permission of the Victoria and Albert Museum. page 36 |
3 | Macready as Othello in 5.2, reproduced from G. Scharf, Recollections of the Scenic Effects of Covent Garden Theatre (1838–39). By permission of the Shakespeare Centre Library, Stratford-upon-Avon. page 45 |
4 | Ira Aldridge as Othello. By permission of the Victoria and Albert Museum. page 54 |
5 | Salvini at different moments in the play, reproduced from The Illustrated Sporting and Dramatic News (17 July 1875). page 57 |
6 | Otello and Iago in Verdi’s opera Otello, reproduced from The Sporting and Dramatic News (26 February 1887). By permission of the Victoria and Albert Museum. page 65 |
7 | Paul Robeson as Othello, directed by Margaret Webster. By permission of the Harvard Theatre Collection, the Houghton Library. page 70 |
8 | Laurence Irving as Iago in 2.3, reproduced from The Bystander, 17 April 1912. page 77 |
9 | Laurence Olivier as Othello. Photograph by Angus McBean. By permission of the Harvard Theatre Collection, the Houghton Library. page 79 |
10 | John Kani as Othello and Joanna Weinberg as Desdemona in 5.2. By permission of Janet Suzman. Photograph by Ruphin Coudyzer. page 94 |
11 | Zoë Wanamaker as Emilia and Imogen Stubbs as Desdemona in 4.3. By permission of the Shakespeare Centre Library, Stratford-upon-Avon. page 101 |
12 | Franchelle Stewart-Dorn as Emilia, Ron Canada as Iago, Patrice Johnson as Desdemona and Patrick Stewart as Othello. By permission of the Shakespeare Theatre, Washington DC. Photograph by Carol Rosegg. page 109 |
It is no longer necessary to stress that the text of a play is only its starting-point, and that only in production is its potential realised and capable of being appreciated fully. Since the coming-of-age of Theatre Studies as an academic discipline, we now understand that even Shakespeare is only one collaborator in the creation and infinite recreation of his play upon the stage. And just as we now agree that no play is complete until it is produced, so we have become interested in the way in which plays often produced – and pre-eminently the plays of the national Bard, William Shakespeare – acquire a life history of their own, after they leave the hands of their first maker.
Since the eighteenth century Shakespeare has become a cultural construct: sometimes the guarantor of nationhood, heritage and the status quo, sometimes seized and transformed to be its critic and antidote. This latter role has been particularly evident in countries where Shakespeare has to be translated. The irony is that while his status as national icon grows in the English-speaking world, his language is both lost and renewed, so that for good or ill, Shakespeare can be made to seem more urgently ‘relevant’ than in England or America, and may become the one dissenting voice that the censors mistake as harmless.
‘Shakespeare in Production’ gives the reader, the student and the scholar a comprehensive dossier of materials – eye-witness accounts, contemporary criticism, promptbook marginalia, stage business, cuts, additions and rewritings – from which to construct an understanding of the many meanings that the plays have carried down the ages and across the world. These materials are organised alongside the New Cambridge Shakespeare text of the play, line by line and scene by scene, while a substantial introduction in each volume offers a guide to their interpretation. One may trace an argument about, for example, the many ways of playing Queen Gertrude, or the political transmutations of the text of Henry Ⅴ; or take a scene, an act, or a whole play, and work out how it has succeeded or failed in presentation over four hundred years.
For, despite our insistence that the plays are endlessly made and remade by history, Shakespeare is not a blank, scribbled upon by the age. Theatre history charts changes, but also registers something in spite of those changes. Some productions work and others do not. Two interpretations may be entirely different, and yet both will bring the play to life. Why? Without setting out to give absolute answers, the history of a play in the theatre can often show where the energy and shape of it lie, what has made it tick, through many permutations. In this way theatre history can find common ground with literary criticism. Both will find suggestive directions in the introductions to these volumes, while the commentaries provide raw material for readers to recreate the living experience of theatre, and become their own eye-witness.
J. S. Bratton
Julie Hankey
A | Athenaeum |
Bell | Bell’s Edition of Shakespeare’s plays, ed. Francis Gentleman, vol. I. Othello, as Performed at the Theatre Royal Drury Lane. Regulated from the Prompt-Book . . . by Mr Hopkins, Prompter, London, 1774 |
BM | Blackwood’s Magazine |
C | Century |
Carroll | Janet Barton Carroll, ‘A Promptbook Study of Margaret Webster’s Production of Othello’, PhD dissertation, Louisiana State University, 1977 |
Cumberland | Cumberland edition. Othello, a Tragedy. Printed from the Acting Copy with Remarks by D-G [George Daniel]. (Issued as part of Cumberland’s British Theatre, vol. II), 1829 |
DT | Daily Telegraph |
EIM | English Illustrated Magazine |
EN | Evening News |
ES | Evening Standard |
FT | Financial Times |
G | Guardian |
Hazlitt | William Hazlitt, The Complete Works of William Hazlitt, ed. P. P. Howe, 21 vols., London and Toronto, 1930–4, vols. V and XVIII |
I | Independent |
IHT | International Herald Tribune |
ILN | Illustrated London News |
IoS | Independent on Sunday |
L | Listener |
LI | Life International |
LM | Lippincott’s Magazine |
LR | Literary Review |
Mason | E. T. Mason, The Othello of Tommaso Salvini, New York: Putnam’s, 1890 |
MG | Manchester Guardian |
MM | Macmillan’s Magazine |
MoS | Mail on Sunday |
MS | Morning Star |
NS | New Statesman |
NS and N | New Statesman and National |
NYT | New York Times |
O | Observer |
Ottley | Henry Ottley, Fechter’s Version of Othello Critically Analysed, London, 1861 |
P and P | Plays and Players |
PQ | Philological Quarterly |
S | Spectator |
SB | Shakespeare Bulletin |
Sh.S | Shakespeare Survey |
Sprague | A. C. Sprague, Shakespeare and the Actors: The Stage Business in His Plays (1660–1905), Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1945 |
SQ | Shakespeare Quarterly |
ST | Sunday Times |
STel | Sunday Telegraph |
T | The Times |
TB | Temple Bar |
TJ | Theatrical Journal |
TLS | Times Literary Supplement |
TO | Time Out |
TQ | Theatre Quarterly |
Variorum | Horace Howard Furness, Othello: A New Variorum Edition of Shakespeare, Philadelphia, 1886, vol. VI |
F1 | The first Folio, published in 1623 |
OED | Oxford English Dictionary |
Q1 | The first quarto, published in 1622 |
Q2 | The second quarto, published in 1630 |
RSC | Royal Shakespeare Company |
WP | Washington Post |
Location is London unless otherwise noted.
Date | Actor(s)/Director | Theatre/medium | |
?1603–18 | Richard Burbage | Globe/Blackfriars | |
1618–42 | Ellyaerdt Swanston | Globe/Blackfriars | |
Joseph Taylor: Iago | |||
1660–9 | Nicholas Burt | The Cockpit, Drury Lane | |
Walter Clun (died 1664): Iago | The Bridges Street Theatre (from 1663) | ||
Michael Mohun (after 1664): Iago | |||
?1674–82 | Charles Hart | The Theatre Royal (hereafter Drury Lane) | |
Michael Mohun: Iago | |||
1682–1709 | Thomas Betterton | Drury Lane | |
Samuel Sandford: Iago (until 1702) | |||
1710–27 | Barton Booth | Drury Lane | |
1720–51 | James Quin | Lincoln’s Inn Fields | |
Colley Cibber: Iago | |||
1734–77 | Charles Macklin: Iago | Haymarket | |
1745–6 | David Garrick (3 performances) | Drury Lane | |
1747–75 | Spranger Barry Macklin, Garrick, Ryan, Bensley: Iago | Drury Lane (Barry was at the Smock Alley Theatre, Dublin, 1744–6) | |
Susanna Cibber: Desdemona | |||
1771–94 | Robert Bensley: Iago | Covent Garden | |
1780–5 | John Henderson: Iago | Covent Garden | |
1785–1805 | J. P. Kemble | Drury Lane | |
Sarah Siddons: Desdemona | |||
Charles Kemble: Cassio | |||
1792 | Francois-Joseph Talma in Ducis’s transl./version | Théâtre-Français | |
1803 | G. F. Cooke: Iago | Covent Garden | |
1814–33 | Edmund Kean J. B. Booth, W. C. Macready, Edwin Forrest: Iago | Drury Lane | |
1816–51 | W. C. Macready | Covent Garden | |
George Vandenhoff, C. M. Young: Iago | |||
Fanny Kemble, Helena Faucit: Desdemona | |||
1827–8 | Edmund Kean | Théâtre Favert, Paris | |
Macready: Iago | |||
1829 | Joanny in Alfred de Vigny’s translation | La Comédie Française | |
Mlle Mars: Desdemona | |||
1833, 1858, 1865 | Ira Aldridge | Covent Garden, Lyceum, Haymarket | |
Ellen Tree, Madge Kendal: Desdemona | |||
1826–71 | Edwin Forrest | The Bowery, New York | |
Drury Lane (1836) | |||
1834, 1836 | Othello Travestie: an operatic burlesque, by Maurice G. Dowling | The Liver Theatre (Liverpool); The Strand | |
1837–72 | Samuel Phelps | Haymarket | |
Sadlers Wells (1844–61) | |||
1848 | Gustavus Vaughan Brooke | Olympic Theatre | |
Queens’ Theatre, Melbourne (1855) | |||
1856 | Charles Dillon | Lyceum | |
1861–2 | Charles Fechter/John Ryder (alternating Othello and Iago) | The Princess’s Theatre | |
1860–9 | Edwin Booth | Winter Garden, New York; | |
Booth’s Theatre, New York (1869–73) | |||
1875, 1884 | Tommaso Salvini | Drury Lane; Covent Garden | |
1876 | Henry Irving | Lyceum | |
Isabel Bateman: Desdemona | |||
1881 | Henry Irving/Edwin Booth (alternating Othello and Iago) | Lyceum | |
Ellen Terry: Desdemona | |||
1881 | Ernesto Rossi | Booth’s Theatre, New York(in 1876 Rossi did extracts from Othello at Drury Lane) | |
1886–1921 | Frank Benson | Shakespeare Memorial Theatre (hereafter Stratford) | |
1889 | Otello by Verdi | Covent Garden (English debut) | |
1898 | Ellen Terry: Desdemona | Grand Theatre, Fulham | |
Frank Cooper: Othello | |||
1902 | Johnston Forbes-Robertson | Lyric | |
1907, 1908, 1911 | Oscar Asche | His Majesty’s Theatre | |
Alfred Brydone: Iago | |||
1907 | Ermete Novelli | Lyric Theatre, New York | |
1910 | Giovanni Grasso | Lyric | |
1912 | Herbert Beerbohm Tree | His Majesty’s Theatre | |
Laurence Irving: Iago | |||
Phyllis Neilson-Terry: Desdemona | |||
1921, 1948, 1949 | Godfrey Tearle | Court Theatre (1921); Stratford | |
1922, 1927, 1943 | Baliol Holloway (alternating Othello/Iago with Abraham Sofaer, 1943) | Stratford | |
1924 | Ion Swinley | Old Vic | |
1929 | H. K. Ayliffe (director) | Birmingham Repertory | |
1930 | Paul Robeson | The Savoy Theatre | |
Peggy Ashcroft: Desdemona | |||
Sybil Thorndyke: Emilia | |||
1930, 1932 | Wilfred Walter | Stratford (1930) | |
George Hayes: Iago (1930) | Old Vic (1932) | ||
Ralph Richardson: Iago (1932) | |||
1931 | Edmund Willard | Arts Theatre | |
1932 | Ernest Milton | St James’s | |
1935 | Abraham Sofaer | Old Vic | |
Maurice Evans: Iago | |||
1938 | Ralph Richardson | Old Vic | |
Laurence Olivier: Iago | |||
Tyrone Guthrie (director) | |||
1940, 1944 | Donald Wolfit | Kingsway (1940) | |
Scala (1944) | |||
1942, 1947 | Frederic Valk | The New Theatre (1942) | |
Bernard Miles: Iago (1942) | Savoy (1947) | ||
Donald Wolfit: Iago (1947) | |||
1943 | Paul Robeson | Shubert Theatre, New York | |
José Ferrer: Iago | |||
Uta Hagen: Desdemona | |||
Margaret Webster (director) | |||
1947 | Jack Hawkins | Piccadilly | |
Anthony Quayle: Iago | |||
1950, 1952, 1954 | Anthony Quayle | Stratford (and on tour in Australia) | |
1951 | Orson Welles | St James’s | |
1952, 1956 | Orson Welles | Film (1952, USA 1956, UK) | |
Michael MacLiammoir: Iago | |||
Suzanne Cloutier: Desdemona | |||
Fay Compton: Emilia | |||
1953, 1957 | Earle Hyman | Jan Hus Auditorium, New York (1953) | |
Shakespeare Festival, Stratford, Connecticut (1957) | |||
1956 | Richard Burton/John Neville (alternating Othello and Iago) | Old Vic | |
1959 | Paul Robeson | Stratford | |
1964 | Laurence Olivier | Old Vic | |
Frank Finlay: Iago | |||
Maggie Smith: Desdemona | |||
John Dexter (director) | |||
1964 | James Earl Jones | The New York Shakespeare Festival, Central Park; The Martinique | |
1965 | Olivier/Finlay/Smith | Film of 1964 Old Vic production | |
Stuart Burge (director) | |||
1968 | Not Now, Sweet Desdemona, by Murray Carlin | Makarere University College | |
1970–1 | Catch My Soul (Rock musical version of Othello) | The Roundhouse | |
1971, 1972 | Brewster Mason | Stratford (1971) | |
Emrys James: Iago | Aldwych (1972) | ||
Lisa Harrow: Desdemona | |||
Elizabeth Spriggs: Emilia | |||
John Barton (director) | |||
1971 | Bruce Purchase | Mermaid Theatre | |
Bernard Miles: Iago | |||
1972 | An Othello, by Charles Marowitz | Open Space Theatre | |
1979, 1980 | Donald Sinden | Stratford (1979) | |
Bob Peck: Iago | Aldwych (1980) | ||
Ronald Eyre (director) | |||
1980 | Paul Scofield | The National Theatre | |
Michael Bryant: Iago | |||
Felicity Kendal: Desdemona | |||
Yvonne Bryceland: Emilia | |||
Peter Hall (director) | |||
1981 | Anthony Hopkins | Television film: BBC (available on video) | |
Bob Hoskins: Iago | |||
Penelope Wilton: Desdemona | |||
Jonathan Miller (director) | |||
1982 | James Earl Jones | Winter Garden, New York | |
Christopher Plummer: Iago | |||
1985, 1986 | Ben Kingsley | Stratford (1985) | |
David Suchet: Iago | Barbican (1986) | ||
Terry Hands (director) | |||
1987 | John Kani | The Market Theatre, Johannesberg, South Africa | |
Richard Haines: Iago | |||
Joanna Weinberg: Desdemona | |||
Janet Suzman (director) | |||
1988 | Kani/Haines/Weinberg (as above) | Television film: ITV/Channel 4 (available on video) | |
Janet Suzman (director) | |||
1989 | Willard White | The Other Place, Stratford | |
Ian McKellen: Iago | |||
Imogen Stubbs: Desdemona | |||
Zoë Wanamaker: Emilia | |||
Trevor Nunn (director) | |||
1990 | White/McKellen/Stubbs/Wanamaker (as above) | Television film: BBC (available on video) | |
Trevor Nunn (director) | |||
1990 | Avery Brooks | Folger Shakespeare Library, Washington DC | |
Andre Braugher: Iago | |||
Franchelle Stewart-Dorn: Emilia | |||
Hal Scott (director) | |||
1995 | Laurence Fishburne | Film | |
Kenneth Branagh: Iago | |||
Irene Jacob: Desdemona | |||
Anna Patrick: Emilia | |||
Oliver Parker (director) | |||
1996, 1998 | Casting Othello, by Caleen Sinnette Jennings | Washington Summer Theatre Festival (1996) | |
Folger Shakespeare Theatre, Washington DC (1998) | |||
1997 | Patrick Stewart | The Shakespeare Theatre, Washington DC | |
Ron Canada: Iago | |||
Patrice Johnson: Desdemona | |||
Franchelle Stewart-Dorn: Emilia | |||
Jude Kelly (director) | |||
1997 | David Harewood | The National Theatre | |
Simon Russell Beale: Iago | |||
Claire Skinner: Desdemona | |||
Maureen Beattie: Emilia | |||
Sam Mendes (director) | |||
1999 | Ray Fearon | Stratford | |
Richard McCabe: Iago | |||
Zoë Waites: Dsdemona | |||
Rachel Joyce: Emilia | |||
Michael Attenborough (director) | |||
2001 | Othello adapted by Andrew Davies | Television film: LWT (available on video) | |
Eamonn Walker | |||
Christopher Ecclestone: Ben Jago | |||
Keeley Hawes: Dessie |